We asked, you answered: Android users pick between gestures and 3-button navigation, and the top choice might surprise you

When setting up a new Android phone, you're often given the choice to use gestures or 3-button navigation, an option you can always change later in the settings. In a recent poll, we asked whether you prefer to use gestures or 3-button navigation on your Android smartphone. Surprisingly, it seems many of you have strong feelings about this, as our poll received over 19,000 responses.

Based on the responses, it seems Android users overwhelmingly favor the 3-button navigation, which received 81% of the votes. As someone who was originally skeptical of gestures but has since fully embraced them, I found this somewhat surprising.

Why people love 3-button navigation

One reader, James, highlights some benefits that come with using 3-button navigation, with a focus on accessibility and clarity:

"Button navigation is *discoverable*. Gesture navigation is not. This is still important to people who aren't as familiar with Android. This is still important for better accessibility.

Buttons also are clearer when it might not be obvious if your phone considers itself to be in portrait or landscape mode."

Another reader, Vrijilesh, gives a good reason why they still use 3-button navigation, which boils down to third-party launchers.

Another reader on X notes that gestures seem to be a mostly iPhone thing and that Android users prefer buttons, a statement that seems to be corroborated by our poll:

Mike Szekely on Facebook makes it clear and simple: "You'll have to pry buttons out of my cold, dead hands."

On the other hand, Alexander on Facebook comes to the defense of gestures, saying it's more accessible than buttons.

"Gesture navigation gives you significantly better control over your device," Turner comments. "Any part of the left or right hand side of my screen becomes the back button instead of me having to stretch my thumb from whatever current position it's at to get to the back button."

Sean also agrees, saying they prefer gesture navigation despite early skepticism.

"Gesture. Didn't think I'd like it at first, but after a day or two on the pixel 5 at the time, I was hooked. Now button navigation feels completely backwards for me."

That said, it looks like the masses have spoken: 3-button is the preferred method over gestures. And while both have their advantages, buttons are the more familiar method that consumers are comfortable with. Fortunately, unlike the iPhone, Android users still have a choice when it comes to navigating their phones.