Galaxy Nexus

Apple ... blah blah blah ... Google ... blah blah blah ... Patent ... blah blah blah ... Search ... blah blah blah ... Banned ... Blah blah blah.

Frankly, Scarlett, I don't give a shit. Lawyers are doing what lawyers are wont to do. This is only growing more ridiculous with each passing day.

In fact, here's how much I don't care. We're going to give away another Galaxy Nexus right here, right now. Because despite this ruling, they're still shipping. It's just lawyers being lawyers.

Here's how to win: Leave a comment in this post about how messed up all this patent nonsense is. We'll pick a winner by noon EST Saturday, June 30. Everyone's invited. Not just in the U.S.

Here are a few links about today's news, if you still wanna read more: ReutersFOSS Patents

 
There are 4944 comments

I'm pretty sure iOS 5 and 6 have more things copied from Android than Android has on Apple combined. As much as I'm a Mac fan, this leaves me disgraced with Apple. How about they start innovating instead of suing companies to gain a foothold. iOS 6 was good, but not good enough. Android already has just about all of the new features that it introduced.

SO WHO WON?

So tired, no energy to left, the ridiculousness has defeated me...

THeys says:

A wise man once said, "An eye for an eye and eventually we all go blind". Apple files suit against Samsung, Samsung sues Apple, Microsoft sues Google, Apple sues HTC, they all sue each other and the consumer pays in the end. I don't think that it will stop until there is a consumer backlash towards all parties involved. So let me say this, STOP THE FOOLISHNESS AND GET BACK TO INNOVATION. A ground breaking product will always win in the end and you won't need courts to fight your battle.

jnsalvado says:

These patent wars reminds me of kids in kindergarden who couldn't stand that other kids had better toys than them!

justin43712 says:

Wheres the winner?!

ryguymoeller says:

"This patent is nonsense" - Wise words from a wise man, Phil Nickinson

smacsteve says:

This is getting to be pretty entertaining! I can't wait to see what Apple cooks up next!

Eff Apple in the capital A, now gimme a GNex!! :)

jsvor says:

Screw apple. They are just scared of a superior product.

tjhop4292 says:

Personal Opinion: Apple is a giant corporate douche.
Not to say that this crap wouldn't happen without Apple, I just don't believe it would on the same scale/severity.

cegc135 says:

Hallo everyone! Fellow venezuelan Android user here, I know I'm very late for this party (time difference, jet lag, or whatever you wanna call it) and that I just signed up, but still I wanna share my comments on this given that I'm a lawyer myself:

This whole Apple vs the world ordeal needs to end for good, no one else but us users and consumers alike are the affected ones, this patent wars must end. Apple & their constant patent lawsuits BS over anything are doing no good to consumers who just aren't into their catalogue... It's like instead of innovating to lure us into buying their products, they try to force everyone to do so by trying to legally ban the competition.

These lawsuits look more of a desperate cry for attention than patent defense, actually it seems they can't take the heat, so instead of creating more innovative products, they rather hurt their competitors just like a spoiled child. Apple's bullying need to end and seems they need to fall hard to remember that to be the best, you gotta bring something new to the table; in my very honest opinion, they need to grow a pair of balls and another pair of brains or just F-OFF for good.

At the end of the day, this makes not only Apple look bad in the public eye but saldy, us lawyers will take fire for this too.

centerwaters says:

Thanks for picking me.

I have never won anything worth over $20, so this will be a nice surprise.

Where should I email my shipping address?

thanks! :)

ArtIsMe89 says:

This is ridiculous.....this is why I hate apple....Google's taking over and apples doin everything they can to stop em....but they can't simple as that Google has the best os and the best devices hands down...teamANDROID!!!

PhilTech says:

I hope ALL Apple iPhones and Apple iPads get be banned in the U.S forever via an ITC patent review that will be finalized in August. Apple is acting like a spoiled brat because people are spending their money else where. Apple needs to get bitch slapped like the greedy F**kers that they are!!!!

nix80908 says:

I agree that it's nonsense. I thought copyrights were to protect customers, not try and eliminate competition... That's what it seems that Apple's trying to do.

PumaNerd says:

Apple needs to get off their soap box!

jmon24 says:

I found a petition online to impeach Judge Koh from the Apple vs Android case. Please show your support. http://www.change.org/petitions/voters-impeach-us-district-judge-lucy-koh

I was gonna order the gsm nexus for my GF as an anniversary gift since it went on sale but looks like I'm a little too late... I put the order in anyway just to see if it will go through. Apple is garbage.

Adirolfx says:

Hahaha Apple so crazy!

supr70nova says:

I'm certainly no legal expert, but with what seems like a new case everyday, things seem to be getting more and more ridiculous.
I understand that companies need to protect their rightful property, but where do you draw the line? Also, is the patent system abused/broken? Are the people who control this sort of thing asking these questions, or do they see all this action as proof that it's working properly?
This is one citizen who doesn't think this is how things are supposed to be working, for what it's worth...

slinky317 says:

Phil, they're still being sold because they still have them stocked in the domestic warehouses. It's only when those run out and they have to import more does this ban come into effect.

Further, this injunction might finally trigger the mobile world war. No longer is this about proxy wars, this decision is a core feature in stock Android and gives Apple a lot of ammo against all the Android manufacturers.

It's time Google gets involved directly to help win this. And let's hope they fight back with patents that aren't FRAND protected.

rperez720 says:

yes this is bull crap to the 3rd power. I don't even understand why a major company like apple that shouldn't have to worry about their customers leaving them because they have a "so called great product". Please apple just go with the rest of them and play it by ear. Not everything you guys thought of first and trust me there are going to be people buying icrap...just not me. ban apple and support Samsung and android

Va1ha11a says:

I'd like the nexus please.

jtc276 says:

Oh, Apple. The Orwellian super company who seeks to force consumers to purchase only the devices they wish to push on them. Any other device manufacturers will be sued for no good reason. I think it's quite hilarious to be frank. It just shows how scared they are that some other company will take away a precious slice of their current market. Screw Apple and screw their business ethics. I appreciate the slight amount of innovation they've added to the market, but otherwise they're just capitalizing on something lesser known and adding it to their products as some "new amazing feature." Classic Apple. And this lawsuit is no different.

Oh, and I'd LOVE to win a Galaxy Nexus!

sparking62 says:

We should stop using Apple products as protest.

dgwilliams says:

Want a sure fire way to stifle innovation, patent it.

jmk261 says:

Show me the love!

I just don't understand this, I'm fed up with both sides. This entire situation is more ridiculous than the fact that it's illegal for us Brits to eat mince pies on Christmas Day.

This patent nonsense is ridiculuos......unless of course it causes spontaneous Nexus giveaways in which case im all for the patent nonsense.

ronin_k says:

Boycot Apple Products
they think as if they invented the world , sick of Apple Attitude

CarterGuy says:

Apple will have its a day when they fall hard. Eventually they'll produce another Newton or Lisa.

CarterGuy says:

Apple will have its a day when they fall hard. Eventually they'll produce another Newton or Lisa.

Mesterio says:

If you were an Apple and you could fling injunctions at people I wonder who would be your next victim??!! HMMM

yak diezel says:

Listen, i had an iphone and honestly i i prefer android over apples toy. too many innovations in apps alone the access to the web and the fact that photos film and music industry people can achieve great thing being able to go from phone to pc is SO worth staying dedicated to the brand. Apple seems very selfish in the way they put the phone together. i hated the fact i couldn't use my sd cards and when my phone got crused (tee hee) it was over for recovery unless i purchased another (boring) iphone. I'm a music fanatic so android defintely satisfies my addiction.

They should bag groceries and name it iCare-about-more-than-just-money... And give it away in third world countries

fridaylatte says:

Tech companies should be competing via technological one-upmanship. These legal jokes are just lining up the wallets of lawyers with absolutely no benefit to consumers nor the companies. In the end, these companies will still be making phones one way or another whether they get sued or not. The real losers here are us consumers, from the slowing down of technological competition and advancement.

Also I'd love to have a Galaxy Nexus!

ikeveei says:

I hate these patent wars, it hurts the consumers :(. Give me the GNEX and I will make a GNex ICS with the filling being an iPhone 4 of course.

It's frustrating because the uninformed end up thinking Apple is right.

bignaz says:

Its apple nuff said. If they had there way. We would be loading punch cards on our phone why a military drone fallows us recording every move we make.

Just a terrible situation all the way around, and it's really mind-boggling how far Apple has fallen. I used to just not use Apple products but still respected the company and what they have done for the tech industry, now it's gotten to the point where I am actively rooting for them to fail.

F4tB4st4rd says:

Whenever a company begins using legal roadblocks to prevent the competition from moving forward it is a clear sign they have lost their creative MOJO. All they have left is to desperately cling to their remaining market share through legal slight-of-hand, in order to keep from sliding down the slippery slope to irrelevance. Accompanied by the few hardcore, fanatic fanboys who will cling to their tiny iPhone and curse the fading light.

davef81 says:

Apple have forgotten how to innovate, now they just litigate. I have either given away or sold all of my Apple equipment because of all the lawsuits. I'm sick of Apple. I no longer want to help fund their patent trolling.

damonaw says:

It is so dumb what apple is doing, i don't know much about patents but they are both phones made by humans... of course they are going to have similarities. i just want google to keep on googleing it up and making some awesome products!

xman350 says:

Galaxy Nexus rules! Would take one over the iPhone anyway....

DPtheKid says:

This sucks because I was looking forward to buying a Galaxy Nexus because my Samsung Galaxy S2 is broken :(

dyastrab says:

Apple just sucks. They didn't invent touchscreens, the smartphone, mp3's or the cloud. Its time to grow up already.

bigtank says:

ME: Siri, who should I sue today?
Siri: Two lawyers walk into a bar, I forget the rest
ME: Siri, that wasn't a joke
Siri: I know but it wasn't a serious question either
Me: Siri, What do you mean?
Siri: #@%&!#@%$$%$@%@% SUE THEM ALL!!!!**Steve Job's Voice**

kstandish42 says:

The fact that this nonsense is still going on, is proof that apple for all of it's supposed technological innovations and discoveries are still lagging far behind Google and android as a result. Apple knowing that its rapidly losing market share to an operating system that continues to become more and more intuitive to the end users needs and wants. Meanwhile apple loses touch with its target demographic by making itself seem petty with these patent litigation proceedings. If they're inability to notice the overall result, results in my getting a galaxy nexus then so be it! :D

syrenz says:

Patent wars are patently ridiculous. But it's same old same old... Would love to win an infringing Galaxy Nexus

p3p3l3pew says:

Patent this!!!!!

Naaji says:

I need it

Naaji says:

Please please please

Naaji says:

Please please please

Not knowing anything about patents or laws or any of that jibber jabber, I think it's ridiculous any company would want to ban a product from a country. Unless you're blatantly ripping off someone, don't bother with this stuff. It ruins competition and makes us as consumers have fewer choices.

adamantan77 says:

I think, they should just concetrate on building better phones for les instead of wasting millions on lawyers and lawsuits... that's just a friggin waste of dollars and aids nobody. It won't give an advantage to anybody on the marketplace. i'd actually rather avoid aple products because of their strategy to eliminate competition through lawsuits instead of better products.

marc300ib says:

This is the reason why I don't like Apple, they just sue everything, they have no real case, they should just quit, I was just Gunna buy one

So sick of apple, this is a load of crap

I remember ordering my Galaxy Tab 10.1 and heard about the ban online I was about to flipshit and smack the next Apple fanboy they are lucky it didnt get banned in the USA. I think Apple does not like competition, their patent disputes are covering a board range of a function and not specific enough. i should just buy a nexus and walk into a Apple store holding it in people's faces.

xshraf says:

apple is ridiculous, Si-ridiculous!

Darkninja92 says:

They just need to all smoke a j together.

DroidXDoes says:

I would like a Nexus Please, I still have a droid x. Cracked screen and all.

tdan76 says:

Don't blame the lawyers, they're just doing their job.

Blame the execs and board at Apple where the business plan is to fight competitors that have a better product in the courtroom, not with innovation or actual product competition.

This is ridiculous. Oh, I'd love to win a free Nexus!

hocvex20 says:

They are just jealous of the success of android

Snowman211 says:

I really wish thaborn. e US justice system would come to realize that software patents, granted by un-informed lawyers who get paid by the number of patents they approve, are no longer becoming viable. Heck, if I recall correctly, the means of searching files and folders (or, you know..... Different sources for information) was even available back in the days of Win98, quite possibly before! Yet when the all mighty Apple says they're the ones that came up with it and place it in a patent request, the lawyer goes "seems good to me!" And a lawsuit is born

jbag1489 says:

I'd love a new Galaxy Nexus to post an anti crapple background on!

Strijder says:

I'm a lawyer and embarrassed by this sad state of affairs...

flatop25 says:

Seriously, I just want to win new Galaxy Nexus! Just pick me. This Samsung VS Apple, consumer doesn't win here, only lawyers...

nefor says:

Apple is just throwing away money right now. Anyway, Android is moving forward, Samsung too. It doesn't matter if someone sues them...

sogajeffrey says:

I hate patent trolls.... freaking apple... Freaking judges... lawyers..... Leemme win a nexus :D

JMuell02 says:

I have no problem with Apples product, but the reason I despise them is for actions like this. They have this snarky attitude about themselves, like they cured cancer. Get over yourself Apple, the sweetness of Android is taking over.

seeingwhite says:

Patently Absurd. Pun intended.

ToxicLizard says:

This patent is why we can't have nice things.

Jake H. says:

Ya know I never felt any real animosity towards apple I've just always preferred android. But ever since these ridiculous lawsuits I've developed a true hatred for them. I'm sure many people feel the same. I just wish the average consumer was as informed as I am so they would know what kind of company they're supporting when they brag about how great their icrap is.

waterbound says:

Crapple makes me sick. I get what they are indicating they want to appear as but its not working. When you talk to people who own a Crapple product, even they are indicating nausea when reading about Crapple this and Crapple that.. A good thing they weren't around when Ford was building cars, they would patent cars or anything with 4 wheels etc!

dsandman87 says:

Haters, they gonna' hate,
Barristers, they gonna' 'bate.
Lawyers, they gonna' law,
When Apples money comes to call.

Syrous44 says:

All i can say glad I live in the great white north. Just picked up a nexus today and loving every sec I use it glad i made switch from a Blackberry. As for crapple those dushbags should worry about their product rather then suing every one. Karma is a bitch all I can say.

The sad thing is that we are in a world which condones such action. Why should an injunction be allowed to happen over a simple patent.

The fact of the matter is that Samsung are violating one patent and due to this suddenly they can't sell their product?

It's absolutely rubbish and I don't get why it cant just end with a cash settlement or better yet just completely throw out the lawsuit like we have seen previously with other companies.

Hopefully all the litigation can stop soon so we the consumer can benefit with more features in our products.

Impulses says:

Anyone that hasn't read judge Posner's ruling and opinion on the Moto/Apple case really should, I think judges are getting really fed up with all this useless litigation and it'll be them who eventually put a stop to it.

stick1300 says:

This really feels like Apple just trying to stamp out further technological improvement, unless it's coming from them.

TheMemphisE says:

WIth all this tomfollery, I finaly decided to purchase a G'Nex from the play store. Out of spite, you see.

And for all the talk about patents being abused, there isn't all that much being linked or said on the subject of what to do about it.

But the EFF has a few ideas of note. https://defendinnovation.org/

Cheers!

allergy says:

How does Apple think this will help them win over their competition? Beat your opponents up with expensive patent wars, ban products and stifle competition.. Lame lame lame! I for one would love the mainstream people to stop buying iPhones for once and start looking for alternatives (such as android!)

jowii says:

Everybody knows apple's new patent is "We've got a patent for that." Pretty soon they will be claiming they have a patent for how people open doors or use a phone like a phone. I bet the judge that is giving apple this injunction is an apple junkie! Why don't you say Siri resembles the Voice search that google has had for the longest time! Apple should be penalized for improper use of patenting gestures as its not exactly a invention but only a human interaction characteristic its like fridge companies patenting a way to open the fridge....

mkm619 says:

This patent trolling reflects how bleak the minds of guys at apple are , not only do they drive the innovation down but also they kill fair competition , they spend huge amounts of money on patent cases and force other parties to do the same which could affect the price of gadgets.also it's just ridiculous how they aim at android , they sue android oems for using ideas that apple originally stole from other oems for example, you can see here that apple didn't "invent" swipe to unlock http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj-KS2kfIr0&feature=player_embedded

This nonsense has to stop because it only comes at our expense.

Sparxy19 says:

I dont even use or own an android phone (even though id really like too!) And i think this is ridiculas! Go away Apple, your useless!

joelexluthor says:

Galaxy Nexus come to Ecuador !

cyleo says:

Patents are an aged system that prevents innovation. For a great historical example look at the story of edison and tesla.

nlee350 says:

1. Any firm defending innovations and patents has their merit since it is quite difficult to create notable innovations in R&D. If people don't get paid enough to innovate, then most people will never try - high risk and high reward.
2. BUT!!!! I blame the judge for slamming a BAN on this device. A fine or some licensing fee sounds much more reasonable than a ****ing ban...
3. QQ find me in corner

rjf111 says:

US judiciary system is the finest that money can buy

keenorhian says:

Things like this drives me from Apple more and more...

devparikh95 says:

Who won????

suizman says:

Dear Apple all rises and falls and the shit will splash you...

oliverhale says:

I think you cite Star Trek as an example of 'Prior Art' for most smartphone patents.

cytracker says:

Apple should patent lawsuits...after all that's all they've done recently...

igoymillan says:

When will the recipient of the free Galaxy Nexus phone be announced? Thank you.

adazamim says:

I was going to ask same question,
It's already past Saturday EST :)

adazamim says:

Really shame on Apple
Ideas are free to fly
I wanna win please :)

VyprNoch says:

Apple may sue itself now for copying iphone designs. Seriously!! This is getting ridiculous every moment, Why cant they accept the challenge? Oh right wait, cuz they are Losers.

The_Engine says:

This is ridiculous. Apple is going to look like RIM in a few years....

tabocaw says:

Apple: We don't Innovate, We litigate!!!!!

sinoako123 says:

apple wants to take over the world

mroddriguez says:

This is just more publicity for Android, Apple sucks...

Naaji says:

jeallybeans

Naaji says:

more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

atg284 says:

I can't wait until the apple fad is over...and it will happen eventually

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

omg so many jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

jeallybean heaven

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

Naaji says:

even more jeallybeans

skywalker363 says:

If you think patent trolling sucks, join EFF: https://www.eff.org/

ljnecesito says:

Who needs iphone anyway? Maybe the judge is an apple fanboy. Lol

Snipperdo17 says:

I agree the current patent complaints are dumb. It's one thing if it was technology that was created and incredibly different and then copied but stuff like 3G patents are just odd.

kingmonty says:

I've been reading your articles for a long time, and just now have decided to get an account (for obvious reasons). Hope I win!

on one hand these companies have the right to sue each other, but on the other they realy shouldn't do it over small things/this is so subjective/. I believe that their companoes would gain so much more if they invested hese same effort and money in developing better products. Peace.

adamatus says:

patent wars r ruining consumer choices!!

madik_ says:

The patent system should be changed as soon as possible which is unlikely. So lets just hope that Apple will finally lose some big case and the judge verdict will make a important precedence and stop most of this nonsense.

Silly Apple

kill4food says:

I used to be an apple fan boy until I found out how shady they are. I had a lot of respect for coming up with things like the iPad and Siri. Then I was Interneting about and found out that other companies had made a similar tablet device with the same specs as the iPad in like 1995. Then one day we had a guest speaker at our college and he was from the military and explained to us that Siri was a military project that Apple bought from them. my point being Apple copies a lot of things from other companies and its about time someone brought attention to it. The fact that they are perusing legal action against Samsung just proves they are too childish to try and win by the rules.
PS please pick me for nexus. Thanks for your consideration.
=)

Stupid "legal" mumbojumbo. How many ways are there to effectively unlock a touchscreen device or call a phone number that appears in text on a touchscreen device? Anything that anyone comes up with, even without bias, will be fundamentally the same idea. Restricting companies from releasing new products just because of these somewhat similar aspects is halting innovation. Soon there will be only be one way to do everything because there won't be any benefit in attempting to make something new for fear of incurring the wrath of Apple's banhammer! Then they're a monopoly like microsoft was and they have nothing again. Apple clearly isn't thinking this through...

The thing that makes Android superior in every way is that it is open source and anyone with the right knowledge can make a contribution. That's what has allowed my original Incredible to run ICS right now! My carrier said it wasn't going to happen, as did HTC, but the developers out there did it. Where else can that happen? Not within Apple's universe, and they know it. So they have to go after anything that they think can help them to slow down the migration from their products to someone else's, but we all know this won't slow it at all. I hope all of this stuff goes away, I am tired of hearing about it.

bobbyfg7 says:

Patent Shmatent ... I say we just slap a big sticker on Kate Upton that says Samsung and a big sticker on Jessica Alba that says Apple and have them wrestle it out in a kiddie pool of jello. Winner take all. Problem solved. Next issue...

maov999 says:

I don't see the sense of all this war. I use to like apple, now I just don't feel getting a product from them.

ObGynKenobi says:

What is funny to me is that apple is doing the same old crap all over again despite the fact that last time it ended up broke and almost disappears.

Ask anyone who was a Mac developer in the 90s, it was HELL! as bad and probably even worst than developing for iphone is right now. I can tell you 90% of all mac minis sold are just because you need a Mac to work on iphones and ipads, else you can't sell the app on the appstore.

Back to the story, so what happened? macs became more expensive than PCs and less powerful, so less users. Then developers realized they didn't have to take apple's crap anymore and moved to Windows and other platforms. So if you bought a mac you were paying more for less, and soon there were no apps at all, so why get one at all?

That's how apple went from having 30% of the PC market to less than 5%, all that in 4-5 years.

Apple sued Microsoft and other companies with GUI-based products. The whole thing lasted for years, and the result? apple lost, and because it wasted so much time with lawyers and crap instead of creating new products MacOS was obsolete, didn't even have actual multitasking, while Microsoft launched WinNT, and the rest is history.

Now it's the same thing: Android 4 is much better than iOS6, and even Wozniak (APPLE'S COFOUNDER BTW) thinks Windows Phone is better than iOS, same story all over again.

The retina displays are a gimmick, soon Android phones will get 1080p screens with a DPI that obliterate's the iphone's. Apple has been losing on the hardware front for years, all they can offer is a pretty case and nothing else.

TBH I would rather not see this company disappear, but given how they keep repeating the same crap that got them in the hole the first time is like apple is trying to destroy itself.

dianalward says:

Patent law needs to be revamped, the rules and function of the patent office are no longer good for inventors nor the public!

Looking to maybe go Android, and this would be the perfect way to go!

iririr says:

Please let it be my first android phone!!

tstout2 says:

All of this patent war stuff is simply BS. I was just talking my father into to ditching his old Moto FLIP RAZR and moving into the smartphone world with a Galaxy Nexus, and now this???? Seriously, does anyone really think Apple should have been granted such arbitrary/general patents in the first place? Who the hell are these people making such decisions? So can AC help my and my father out and give us a GN?

ofutur says:

I feel for the American public who have to live with such a poor patent system. Hopefully someone will have the balls to put an end to silly software patents.

yogi1574 says:

Honestly this is gonna go on for as long as apple and samsung exist, so just let me have that galaxy so i can rub it in the face of my whole family who has iPhones!! thanks guys!

In an unsurprising move, Apple sues every culture using the letter 'i' in their vocabulary, claiming someone may confuse this with their popular iEverything brand.

GatorGrad says:

I gotta get me one of these!

jfitts75 says:

Only got one statement for Apple, quit stifling competition and JUST MAKE SOMETHING BETTER and quit trying to force everyone else on YOUR development cycle!!!

skunk8pe says:

The worst thing is that greed and closed mindedness are stifling innovation. Let the consumers decide with their wallets.

itoilet says:

Google, skip a year of R&D and bitch slap apple down a notch or two. If anyone has the resources to take on that bully, you do. Next thing you know, apple will be suing ihop for trademark infringement. Now that I think about it, I can't believe it hasn't already happened.

Thanks

n-strike says:

I'm starting to think they weren't really giving one away.

KeenanBrah says:

Blah blah witty comment, blah blah Google for the win, blah blah gimme gimme. But in all.seriousness I would ADORE a S3 :)

smccloud says:

Yep, because Apple never rips other companies patents off. *rollseyes*

The patent system really needs good reform.

dloseke says:

The patent thing is just getting old...I don't want to hear any more about it, except I do. :-)

ep1963 says:

A patent on something big and important may be ok, but this bull that apple is getting away with too much for things that are too little, and it is really getting to the point of damaging progress.

God, where would we be if this kind of patent nonsense had been ongoing for the last 20 years?

adazamim says:

Ideas are free to fly
I wanna win,
When will you announce the winners?

ctk4949 says:

Eff you crapple!!!!!!
Why don't you try to sue Google?!?!
Bunch of cowards!!

seinjunkie says:

I can't help but think that if patents weren't so impossibly busted at a fundamental level, Apple might come up with a really innovative way to manage them and their limits.

Alex_pb says:

Can you imagina if this patent war was done in all the other industries? Cars, clothes, bicycles, buildings or anything else?

Kegman says:

This is what gets my goat especially with the nexus patent suit. To block the sale of the device the patent in question must majorly be responsible for the sales of the device. We are back to slide to unlock? the nexus runs stock android, they aren't even suing the right people. I hope one day the courts start laying down the ban hammer.

#boycottapple...'nuff said.

jyoungjr says:

Apple Smapple....

Everyone already covered the important stuff I just need a new phone anyway thanks

tabormeister says:

It seems like Apple's legal team would undergo gender reassignment sans anaesthetics rather than have a reasonable thought

barnabyh says:

Let's innovate instead of pouring money into lawsuits that only stifle competition. If you can't create a better product for an edge, get the F* out!!

SkinsFan1987 says:

This whole thing is silly and immature. Let the phones ship, and let the consumers make their choice!

Nonsense, I tells ya'...nonsense! But if it gets me a free phone...

kamiller42 says:

Apple is continuing its journey as the new old. Time to call patent busters.

In other news, patents are so hip these days, the patent office is opening 4 more locations: Dallas, Silicon Valley, Detroit. Denver. True story.

Premium1 says:

Cook and Duarte should go winner take all bare knuckle brawl lol.

dhotiram says:

Apple is threatened by Google for software and Samsung for hardware. IOS 6 does not have much to offer compared to Jelly Bean. They are behind in screen size and 4g capable phones on the hardware side. These lawsuits indicate their in-securities.

dummyaj says:

I think Apple never want to learn his mistake about this patent fight,
but at least Apple and Samsung layers having a great after court party for every court they went (using money from Apple and Samsung :) ).

Money...money...money

dbareis says:

The patents need to have a shorter lifespan and you should not be able to sit on them and not use them. They should also not be able to block products but if its fair they should get some money from each sale.

osotramposo says:

Buncha garbage- the whole system

krisguy says:

This patent nonsense makes it difficult for people to earn a living. I work in wireless (AT&T - full disclosure), and I had several customers mad at me when I told them the HTC One X got held up due to Apple's injunction. This makes everyone look bad: Apple looks like a bully, HTC looks like a criminal, the salespeople look like idiots because of launch dates that change on the fly.

Apple reuses designs and gets called geniuses. Someone else does it, like Samsung, then they are criminals.

djluis48 says:

So who won the phone? :P

djluis48 says:

So who won the phone? :P

DuncanBishop says:

Apple : I know this is just your way to slow Google/Android/Samsung's growth..But dam...Alot...And I mean Alot of people love,like want,use there products and this lawsuit stuff will in some shape or form backlash back at Apple. Steve Jobs wanted to murder android and it looks like Apple will do its best to keep that train rolling. But watch what you guys do..alot of us are your customers too!

bashdrew says:

poor apple!

vcsg01 says:

waaa! Love apple computers and use a Nexus but all this lawsuit nonsense is just rediculous

mimogear says:

Well here's the gist of the effed uppyness.

The patent office is a lazy butt.
Boom Apple comes in and boom a patent.
The patent was super general.
Now that one patent can rule all other ideas.
But wait, do the judges actually analyze what's happening?
Is there possibly another way to accomplish what the patent accomplishes?

They've made their crap SOO GENREAL and SOO GENERIC that it's virtually impossible to get around legal punishment! They are patenting the fundamental ways we interact with devices. They are patenting generic shapes. They are being complete d!(^s!!!!!! Just because they don't want to change what they already have and spend a hair more time creating an original idea.

Mother effer!!! My twitter feed is filled with effing hate posts because of their filthy rotten tactics.

MaddmattH says:

I hope Apple gets hit back with an iPhone ban. What would be even better though is if these messed up laws were fixed. It's too easy for companies like Apple to destroy small businesses with these tactics.

And I want me a Galaxy Nexus :D

azrael.arach says:

Whole patent system is screwed and unless it changes soon custumers will be screwed.

mjkneuro#ac says:

The games people play.........

repete153 says:

Apple is a walled garden full of rotten apples. (typing this on a Macbook). iShall never buy Crapple again. Give me sweet jellybeans!

sfbates says:

Uugghh now its officially not for sale. What a waste of time. We know it won't hold for longer than a few days

Gamisou says:

Booo hooo!
C'mon Apple, put on your big girl panties.

One of the best examples of crony capitalism I've seen of late. It's the problem that naturally comes when the government gets to be a big enough stick: people start swinging it around.

So Steve Jobs, ever the fox, persuades Xerox to let him have a glimpse of Xerox’s innovative graphic’s user interface, and then returns to Apple and orders his company to copy and improve upon it. By the time the first Apple Macintosh is introduced, Apple has not only improved the interface but also lowered the cost of its little computer. And we are reminded that this is not theft—it is innovation.

America and the American dream, Apple tells us, is nothing if it is not about innovation.

Now years later Steve Job introduces yet another Apple product—a remarkable little pocket computer he calls the iPhone. And companies around the world see its potential and rush to copy and improve upon it. And improve they do. New phones come out that are not only slimmer and faster and more functional but also are much more affordable.

And what does Apple, the lover of the American Dream, do? It tries to squash the competition. It finds a judge who can be persuaded that its competitor’s phone is mostly just a reproduction of its own little device. And on these grounds the judge issues a judicial order restraining the manufacturer from selling its phone within the borders of the United States.

America and the American dream, Apple now shows us, is nothing if it is not about protecting its market and keeping its pot of money all to itself

So America in the end is about politics. And here Ambrose Bierce’s definition of politics will do quite well: “a strife of interests masquerading as a conflict of principles.”

As my grandmother used to tell me, “Every fox smells his own hole.”

RogerAstley says:

I won't say I will never buy another Apple product, but they are really starting to annoy me.

mrbates says:

My wife loves her iPhone, I love my Androids. I was telling her about the lawsuits and she says: "They are suing because whoever makes those droids you like is making improvements? Improvements that could potentially even boost their sales...and suing the same company that makes the hardware for the iPhone? Ok, that is just dumb. Can you buy me one of those droid phones when I am due for an upgrade" I am going to pay full retail for a new Android for her this weekend--just to get the iPhone4s out of the house.

I love my wife!

jawniest says:

My HTC Thunderbolt just crapped out on me, I need this GNex!! I will never buy an iPhone, especially because of this type of shit.

LV23 says:

Is this a patent law issue or pour judgment of the judge?
This is the question!

AC seems to like talking about how insignificant these suits are, but what they seem to be forgetting is that this is anticompetitive behavior which is unacceptable business practice. Moreover, it's expensive to wage these legal wars, and that cost is getting passed directly to us, the consumers. Thanks, but I don't need my device to cost more just so lawyers can wage their stupid wars. Plus, Google's patch to circumvent this patent is unacceptable as well, as it cripples the GNex's device search functionality. Apple is afraid they can't compete, so they force Google to dumb Android down to their level, and Samsung to charge more for the devices to cover their legal fees. Am I exaggerating? Yes, somewhat; however, the fact remains that these legal wars are having a detrimental effect on the industry. I see the value of not catastrophizing, but let's not go Ostrich Algorithm on it either.

#InnovateNotLitigate #DefendInnovation http://defendinnovation.org/

maxred31768 says:

Apple always tries 2 put everything on lock. Thank God it didn't work:-)

slimjago says:

jazz995756 says:

Apple really needs to stop they already have so much money as it is I'm pretty sure they can afford to loose a couple hundred besides they don't have any reason to complain they're mobile is has the same design since day 1 all android istrying to do is make the user experience better instead of just adding useless features like most of apples iOS releases you can't blame anyone for trying to be fun. Apple simply needs to back of every once in a while I'm sure they violate patents every now and then to I mean no one is perfect.

AndroidBaum says:

Forget the Apple injunction on quick search box for Samsung Nexus and Galaxy S III. This new app on GooglePlay does most of what was removed because of the injunction http://bit.ly/NG8y7b

ACTUALLY apple is jealous as hell after s3 and they dont want competition.(by the way so many comments that thers almost one in a hundred chance any1 wud get gnex. :)

psssss ( i want me a galaxy nexus for the past 6 months.... ;) )

Also,after all this shit i am a bigger fan of samsung than i was b4

Joanierose says:

Is it still possible I could get a galaxy Nexus and your give away? I was given the samsung fascinate smartphone after my stroke in May of 2012, but it is not connected to any network. The part of my brain that died in te stroke was my memory, & vocabulary. And I am already disabled with rheumatoid arthritis, so having the option to speak into the phone makes it easier for me, though I can type, do to a spinal birth defect I cannot sit up long enough to use a PC or laptop. The reasons I joined this form tonight, is because I don't think this phone has much time left, and it keeps freezing up, after it gets so physically hot to the touch, I have to pull the battery. That is why I joined this formum to see if there is a way to reboot this phone without pulling the battery. Because I do not know if I am doing more harm than good. I have been wanting the Google Nexus tablet, saw a commercial recently, and actually first heard about this tablet in Aug 2012. It would be light enough for my hands to hold. I am only 43 try old, and a single parent of 2, and I am on SSI, so I can't afford to just go buy a tablet, or a phone. That's why this 1 was given to me after the stroke to help me store things I cannot remember, doctor appointments, phone numbers, school events, medication reminders, etc. I was so afraid tonight when it got really hot, and friends stopped again, I am not connected to a network so I have no way to have all of this backed up if it fries, so I did a google search on how to reboot a Samsung phone and found this formum. I am very glad I did because I've read a lot of posts, and you guys know your stuff. So I joined, and added you to my pocket app. I love that app, especially since I cannot find how to open my bookmarks! LOLOL! So hopefully you're still giving away that tablet!!!!! But before I go, I would just like to say I don't really know how to answer about that apple versus Google Nexus Injunction, I don't really know anything about Apple, Except I have never used 1, Only thing I really can say Is that a must be anal asses To pick on something so small And insignificant, And they must have a lot of money to throw away, They would have been better off to just give it to charity For example So organizations That take care of sick and injured animals That are homeless, And have been neglected, Can get the proper treatment, medications, food and housing because they deserve love more than a lot of humans do. People can be very cruel.
well thank you for listening, I apologize for going on and on, please forgive me this is jus t 1 side effect the stroke has had on my life. It's only been 4 months, and I'm doing the best I can, because my main priority is to be the best Mom I can be.
Sincerely, Joanierose. I will include my email address that doesn't consist of my full name because this is a little embarrassicom
whitetigersoul216@gmail.com

sroesch says:

Holy cow, looks like I'm going to win some awesome things :)