Motorola Droid XYBOARD

It's been a long year for Android tablets. Motorola was first to the Honeycomb party with the Motorola Xoom. And while it was the quasi-official developer tablet (and really no slouch of a device), the Xoom was quickly overshadowed by lighter, slimmer tablets. And so the Xoom languished. But at least it languished in good company as it and every other Honeycomb tablet has remained that -- a Honeycomb tablet. Little progress has been made, from a consumer standpoint, in getting 2011's tablets off of that interim version of Android.

And that brings us to the Motorola Droid XYBOARD. Actually, a pair of XYBOARDs. Motorola's got a 10.1-inch version as well as an 8.2-incher. They've been redesigned -- slimmer, sleeker, and with a few oddball design cues. But they're still running Honeycomb. And they're still pricey.

Will they be enough to turn the tide for Motorola's Android tablet stable? Read on for our complete Motorola Droid XYBOARD review.


The Good

A worthy upgrade from the Motorola Xoom. Nice to see an 8-inch version alongside the full 10-incher. Faster and more svelte than the Xoom. Nice industrial design.

The Bad

Ugh. The XYBOARD name (never mind that we're playing along with the capitalization game) is awful. And the tablet's still pricey and launched with Honeycomb.

Conclusion

The XYBOARD isn't a bad tablet -- far from it. But what does it bring to the tablet in 2012 that other tablets haven't already done in 2011?

Inside this review

More info

For our purposes, we're mostly going to review both versions of the XYBOARD as if they're a single tablet. We'll mention differences where applicable, and we'll talk about the overall feel of the two sizes. But for all intents and purposes, save for screen size and battery capacity, you're looking at the same device.

The name

Let's just get this out of the way: XYBOARD is a horrible name. Not that smartphones and tablets have a habit of being well-named, but XYBOARD just about takes it, save for the Sprint Samsung Galaxy S II Epic 4G Touch. Have you seen the Verizon commercials for the Droid RAZR where if you buy one, you get $100 off a Droid XYBOARD? Nothing in that statement tells you (nor does the commercial show you) what the hell you're getting $100 off of.

There's cute, and then there's tech sexy -- and XYBOARD is neither. That doesn't (or at least shouldn't) weigh on our review, or your decision to purchase. But that doesn't mean the name's not ridiculous. There. We feel better now.

The video walkthroughs

XYBOARD 10.1 walkthrough


Youtube link for mobile viewing

XYBOARD 8.2 walkthrough


Youtube link for mobile viewing

The hardware

As is the case with tablets, the XYBOARD at its core is a screen and a big battery, with parts crammed in between. That hasn't changed here. But whereas the original Xoom was fat and heavy (at least by most 2011 tablet standards), the XYBOARD has shaved off those corners and slimmed down a bit. It's still not terribly light -- the XYBOARD 10.1 did shave off about 130 grams, down to 603 -- but it's noticeably slimmer at 8.8mm thin. (The Xoom is 12.9mm.)

Motorola XYBOARD

Not a lot to say about the front of the XYBOARD -- it's a big screen. You definitely can tell where they redesigned the corners. We actually prefer the rounded look for aesthetics, but the XYBOARD definitely has differentiated itself here.

The XYBOARD has a front-facing 1.3MP camera, for what it's worth, and there's a hidden notification light tucked nearby.

Motorola Droid XYBOARD

Flip it over, and that's where the real design flare is found. Motorola's gone full industrial on the XYBOARD -- it very much looks and feels like the Droid RAZR's big brother. There's a metallic plate in the middle, mated to the body by exposed screws. The Motorola and Verizon logos are in full display in the center. 

Ringing the metallic plate and continuing to the bezel is soft-touch plastic. It looks nice, feels nice and does a good job at providing grip as the metallic plate most certainly does not.

Motorola XYBOARD

The power button and volume buttons are tucked flush into the soft-touch ring. It's an interesting design choice, and we never did manage to get used to them being there. It's an awkward reach-around if you want to change volume on the fly, and there's not enough differentiation in feel between the power and volume buttons. Is it the worst thing in the world? No. But more often than not we find ourselves fumbling for the buttons instead of instinctively pressing them.

There's a 5MP camera with flash tucked into the usual place on the top short side.

Motorola XYBOARD

On the XYBOARD 8.2, the microUSB, HDMI and SIM card ports (with the latter hidden behind a door) are all on the bottom short side bezel. Yes, we said microUSB, praise the almighty Bugdroid. We're back to microUSB for charging and syncing, though note that the tablets will charge slower when connected to a computer via microUSB. There is a pair of speakers tucked down here, too. And as usually is the case with Motorola speakers, they're good.

Motorola XYBOARD

The XYBOARD 10.1 has its ports on the bottom long edge, and the speakers have been moved to the rear of the device.

The top edges of the XYBOARDs have an antenna and 3.5mm headphone jack. 

What's under the hood

Motorola's traded in the first dual-core Tegra 2 processor for a dual-core TI OMAP 4430 running at 1.2 GHz. It's plenty fast, as you'd expect. But it's already been eclipsed by the new quad-core devices that are starting to hit the market. It's nothing to turn your nose up at, but neither is it bleeding-edge. The XYBOARD's got a full 1GB of RAM, as it should.

As for onboard storage, you're looking at a few options. The XYBOARD 10.1 comes in 16GB, 32GB or 64GB flavors, and the XYBOARD 8.2 comes in 16GB or 32GB versions. (The new Wifi-only version XYBOARDs only come in 16GB or 32GB varieties.)

With big tablets come big batteries, and the XYBOARDs are no exception. The XYBOARD 10.1 has 7000 mAh at its disposal, while the 8.2 takes things down to 3960 mAh. We found typical battery life for tablets -- and typical battery life for LTE devices. The faster the data, the bigger the suck. You'll want to use Wifi when you can to save on battery life.

Verizon's LTE works as Verizon's LTE does. When it's connected, it's nice and fast.

The software

Motorola XYBOARD

The XYBOARDs are running Android 3.2 Honeycomb, and Motorola already has promised an update to Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich. There's not a whole lot here that we haven't seen on countless tablets over the past 12 months, but Motorola has thrown in a few of its better improvements, like the MOTOPRINT service for wireless printing. There's been a tad of skinning of icons, but nothing that should bother you.

Motorola XYBOARD

This being a non-Google Experience device (unlike the Xoom), Verizon and Moto have preloaded a few apps for you. The standouts are Amazon Kindle, BlockBuster, VCAST Apps, Audio Effects, GoToMeeting, Let's Golf 2, Madden NFL 12, MotoCast, MotoPack, My Verizon MobileQuickoffice HD, Skitch, Slingbox, VCAST Media Manager, VideoSurf and VZ Navigator.

Motorola XYBOARD

We mentioned this in the hands-on video, but Motorola deserves some kudos for putting its privacy policy front-and-center. You get a notification in the System Bar, and the privacy document, while long, does a nice job of telling you everything you're agreeing to -- and whom to contact with questions. 

Otherwise, not a lot to say about the software. It's Honeycomb. We're not expecting any major UI changes with Ice Cream Sandwich. If that changes, we'll revisit.

The camera

Motorola XYBOARD

What's old is new again. Same old Honeycomb camera app, which is decent enough. You've got plenty of modes and scenes to play with.

As for quality of the images, let's go to the examples ...


Youtube link for mobile viewing

The wrap-up

We've said before that somebody had to be first to the tablet race, and that was Motorola with the Xoom. The XYBOARD 10.1 and XYBOARD 8.2 are decent enough tablets, and they're nice improvements on the Xoom. We're also delighted to see an 8.2-inch version launch alongside the more traditional 10.1-incher. There's absolutely a place for the smaller size.

But as is too often the case with major-manufacturer devices, they're just too damn expensive. The Wifi-only verison of the XYBOARD 8.2 is going for $399, and that's not horrible. But neither does it make the $200 Kindle Fire or $250 Nook Tablet look less attractive. And if you're going with a Verizon LTE version, don't forget about the added cost of montly data fees.

And we're really not knocking the XYBOARD's hardware -- it's damn nice. But it's damn nice for 2011. Nothing wrong with that at all, but we can't help but wonder how long it'll take Motorola to get some quad-core fare, and that gives us pause in recommending the XYBOARD. 

 
There are 11 comments

Viper says:

+1 on the name. I didn't realize it was pronounced "ZYBOARD" until I saw that commercial. Really stupid Moto. Are you trying to reinvent the sounds of letters? And on top of that, I wouldn't want to associate a tablet I produced with a 2x4 piece of lumber, which is what the "BOARD" brings to mind.

Someone in the Moto naming department deserves to be fired.

WAldenIV says:

Xylophone has a "zee" sound.

sveilien says:

I haven't seen the commercial. I thought it was called "Ecks-why-board" up until now.

richard_rsp says:

I recently have been looking for a more portable solution than my iPad, and actually had one of the 8.2" Xyboards for a week... I had already tried the 7" Galaxy Tab 3G, and the 7" Galaxy Tab Plus 4G (tmobile), but the Gtab was old, and the Gtab plus had some pretty big glitches (plus only on tmobile).

I really liked the Xyboard, however the initial cost plus monthly data plan was too much to justify keeping. There were some minor flaws (screen flickering, charge light not working) but those were likely to be addressed in future updates.

The name is just silly. I wish they would have stuck with calling it the Xoom 2 over here, or something else entirely.

I think it should be priced at $199 with contract... It's hard to justify more than that with a $30 data plan each month. With that type of price, i think that significantly more people would be interested in the Xyboard.

WAldenIV says:

Try the GTab 8.9.

richard_rsp says:

Too big. I need something to fit in my pocket... the Xyboard 8.2 BARELY would fit in my coat pocket (but it would fit, with the portfolio case), and I found myself not carrying it around as much as a 7" because I didnt want to squeeze it into my coat.

Plus there is no GTab 8.9 for Verizon. AT&T does not have 4G in our area.

jimbarr says:

Hmmm. Maybe I'm the only one (since I have never seen it mentioned anywhere else) but when I first saw the name "Xyboard", I assumed it was a play on the word "cyborg" in keeping in line with the DROID genre.

dorelse says:

Nope, you're not the only one...I also thought it was a play on the Droid line with 'cyborg'. They should have named it cyborg or something (cybord)...and just keep it at that.

jakson0100 says:

The only things I like about my xyboard 8.2 is the size. Otherwise it'sas bad as my droid phone.

i like it. the only people that want to show off what their tablets name is people that own ipads. Moto could have stuck w/ xoom or xoom 2 or just call it ZYBOARD.
But the thing i like the most is that it has a flash on the rear camera. Ive had multiple tablets & all of them had bad cameras front & rear. i cant wait to get my hands on this tablet. i have my HTC evo view 4g tablet for sale. i like it, but i switched over to verizon.

Well after a year and a half my xyboard 10.1 has become a piece of junk. Problems with charging on the mini usb... now it won't charge at all! AND if it does it charges very slowly and discharges quickly. Yes Yes you say the port was "stretched" or loosened. For the price I paid the technology should have been better. Gees, I bought the whole package, razor, tablet and keyboard. I even bought the extended warranty on the phone, they break easily. I did not expect that the tablet would have had the charging problems and did not buy the extended warranty. Gees the whole tablet thing has been VERY expensive. Even verizon let me down. We moved so my verizon store location changed. My store in PA had it together, this Salisbury MD store does not have their act together. In January this year I went into the Salisbury Verizon store with the charging problem... usb port, slow charge, fast discharge... they told me my tablet was out of manufacture warranty... AND you did not buy the extended warranty, SORRY!. Finally disgusted I called Motorola in June... they told me the warranty was good until March and NOW out of warranty, SORRY! Problem is I love the Android format. Done with Motorola phone, tablet... anything. Done with Verizon in December... Any suggestions? And don't say buy the extended warranty next time ;-)