Amazon Echo Dot (3rd Gen) vs. Echo Dot With Clock: Which should you buy?

Amazon announced this week that it added several new Echo devices to its smart home lineup, including an updated version of its extremely popular Echo Dot, which features an LED display to show the time, the weather, or timers. Is it worth getting the new hotness, or will the 3rd Gen do you just fine? Let's find out!

Time to connect the dots

Source: Android CentralPictured: Echo Dot with Clock.

You'd be forgiven if you couldn't tell the difference between these two Echo Dots at first glance. They share the same dimensions, the same design, and similar colors. They are even comparably priced! With all of their similarities out of the way, let's take a look at what sets these two Dots apart from each other.

	Echo Dot (3rd Gen)	Echo Dot with Clock
Weight	10.6 oz	10.6 oz
Microphones	4	4
Speakers	1.6" speaker	1.6" speaker
Line-out with 3.5 mm cable or Bluetooth	Yes	Yes
Smart Home Controls	Yes	Yes
LED Display	No	Yes
Music Streaming	Yes	Yes
Pair Multiple for Stereo Sound	Yes	Yes
Free Audio Calls to the U.S., Mexico, and Canada	Yes	Yes
Finishes	Fabric (4 colors - charcoal, heather gray, sandstone, plum)	Fabric (1 color - sandstone)

Tick, tock, which Dot?

Source: Android CentralPictured: Echo Dot (3rd Gen).

The Echo Dot with Clock is the new sibling in the Dot family, and you could consider it a nice iteration on the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) model. It now has an LED display that has been integrated into and behind the fabric cover, and it can auto-adjust the brightness of the clock depending on the brightness of your room. It's no-frills and no-fuss. There's no ugly screen to stare at, and no worries of a camera staring back at you in your bedroom like there is with the Echo Show.

The LED display can show you the time, temperature, and a countdown of any timers you ask Alexa to set. It can also serve as your alarm clock, and all you have to do to shut it up is tap the top of the Dot. Easy peasy! Finally, this enhanced Echo Dot comes in at only $10 more than the 3rd Gen, so it is almost a no-brainer upgrade.

While those do sound like really good features to add to an already popular device, the Echo Dot (3rd Gen) is no slouch. It is still the cheapest Echo smart speaker you can buy, and it can often be found at Amazon on sale, or even as part of a smart-home bundle with smart plugs or lightbulbs for an even better value. The new features on the Echo Dot with Clock are nice to have, but there are surely some people who may decide that they do not want any kind of light or display on a device that might be meant to be tucked away. Different Dots for different folks?

Time to make a decision

Okay, enough of the terrible time puns... which of these Echo Dots should you get? I think Amazon made this choice easy for consumers by pricing the new Echo Dot with Clock at just $10 more than the Echo Dot (3rd Gen). This newer version took all that was good with the previous version, didn't remove anything, and added really useful functionality for a fair price. I can't argue with that logic! This makes it easy to make the Echo Dot with Clock my preferred option, and the one I think you should get too.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.