With 5G, should carriers to continue limiting mobile hotspots?

Mobile Hotspot Zenfone
Mobile Hotspot Zenfone (Image credit: Samuel Contreras / Android Central)

Mobile hotspot, also known as tethering, is a feature on smartphones that allows them to share mobile data with any Wi-Fi device. This feature is a staple for many people that work from the road, whether they need a connection to process a payment or just want a little entertainment in the truck after a long day of driving.

While most of the best cell phone plans come with enough data for a little coffee shop browsing, those that spend a lot of time on the road can run out quickly. Carriers have promised increased speed and capacity with 5G connectivity, but most plans still don't reflect this upgrade, even as some LTE and 3G networks are shuttered for 5G development.

How does hotspot data work right now?

Most modern phone plans come with some hotspot data, and when you need it, it's great to have. T-Mobile, as an example, comes with 40GB of high-speed hotspot per month on its most expensive Magenta Max plan. Unfortunately, this data slows down to what T-Mobile describes as 3G speeds if you use that whole amount. Furthermore, T-Mobile requires that your primary data usage be used on your phone, not your hotspot. The other major carriers are similar in their restrictions though, AT&T and Verizon's cheapest unlimited plans won't work with a mobile hotspot at all.

40GB is a good amount for browsing and SD streaming, but if you want to download a large file such as a game from Steam on your laptop, you can go through it in a flash. It's worth noting that if you have a limited plan like AT&T's 4GB plan or a prepaid carrier like Tello, you can use all of your data in a hotspot.

Visible, on the other hand, includes an unlimited hotspot for one device though it's limited to just 5Mbps. Large downloads will take a long time on this slow connection, but the fact is that you can leave it going all day. Streaming from your smartwatch or tablet is easier and can even make the battery last longer since it won't need to connect to mobile data.

How can 5G change things?

Motorola Edge Plus 5g Test

Source: Michael Fisher (Image credit: Source: Michael Fisher)

Low-band sub-6 spectrum is the core of each carrier's nationwide 5G network. This spectrum is fantastic for coverage but lacks the bandwidth to deliver speeds much greater than a well-developed LTE network. While it is real 5G, it will succumb to congestion as more and more people upgrade to one of the best Android phones with 5G support. Sometimes it can be hard to remember why you upgraded at all.

Mid-band, C-band, and especially mmWave should have much less trouble when traffic increases. T-Mobile has a lot of mid-band spectrum at 2.5GHz with some more C-band spectrum for urban areas. In addition to this, each carrier has some C-band, and mmWave spectrum will be able to cope with crowds and high-density areas, though there are coverage and availability challenges as C-band will still take some time to open up.

When you run a speed test on T-Mobile's mid-band, you'll see speeds over 300Mbps most of the time, with peaks much higher. T-Mobile has also managed to cover 165 million people with this level of 5G as of mid-2021.

T-Mobile C-Band 2.5GHz Comparison

Source: T-Mobile (Image credit: Source: T-Mobile)

While 5G coverage is growing and capacity is improving with further upgrades in the works, as more people adopt 5G, it still faces many of the same challenges LTE did with capacity.

Verizon stands out when it comes to 5G capacity. While AT&T has been steadily making progress with mmWave, especially in large buildings like airports and stadiums, Verizon has continued to add cities to its Ultra Wideband coverage and improve within others. In addition, Verizon's top unlimited plans come with access to Ultra Wideband, and one major perk is unlimited mobile hotspot while connected.

It remains to be seen if this perk will continue as Verizon rolls out C-band 5G under the same name, but for now, if you live and work in an area with coverage, you can get some amazing speeds without touching public Wi-Fi.

Tmobile Home Internet 5g Lifestyle

Source: Chris Wedel/Android Central (Image credit: Source: Chris Wedel/Android Central)

Verizon now has also found a way to monetize this expensive deployment early with its fiber-like 5G Home internet service. 5G Home is available in 57 cities and is one of the first competitors to cable and fiber services in years by exclusively using mmWave. With a fixed antenna location, Verizon is able to circumvent coverage challenges and offer a stable and fast connection to eligible households.

T-Mobile's home internet also demonstrates how 5G can be used to offer unlimited high-speed internet at home. However, T-Mobile's approach is more focused on rural customers and relies more on slower 5G and even LTE to get things done. Still, having access to an unlimited broadband connection at all is a significant upgrade for many people.

What about a speed limit?

Visible set the bar low with a 5Mbps unlimited hotspot, but the idea makes a lot of sense. Letting customers loose to download 100GB video games or stream 4K video will put a lot of strain on the network. In these terms, a speed cap like home internet providers use makes more sense. This will allow people to continue to use the internet in an unrestricted way but can spread the burden of large, low-priority downloads over a longer period of time.

Carriers could also take a page out of the satellite internet provider HughesNet's book with Bonus Zone. Bonus Zone grants customers 50GB of additional data between 2 a.m. and 8 a.m., so speeds stay high during peak hours but still allows large downloads if you're willing to do a bit of planning. Most operating systems, as well as Steam, will enable you to schedule updates. At the end of the day, the internet is still a shared resource, so it makes sense to spread the load out as thinly as possible.

Should we want a plan for every device?

Photo of the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE in DeX mode with multiple windows

Source: Jennifer Brown / Android Central (Image credit: Source: Jennifer Brown / Android Central)

Data plans made for tablets are competitive and often quite good values. These plans have a lot in common with phone plans and even have unlimited options with their own mobile hotspot feature. Still, the problem remains that you're adding another monthly payment to your account for a single device to get connected. You'll also need the more expensive LTE or 5G variant of tablet like the Galaxy Tab S7.

My first internet connection involved a phone line, so picking up an always-connected laptop or tablet feels like magic, but I don't look forward to a future where all of my connected devices have their own 5G connection. Instead, I like the idea that I can upgrade my home network whenever I want, and all of my devices benefit.

There are also dedicated mobile hotspots. Hotspot plans work with 5G hotspots and can come with a ton of data for a reasonable price. For example, T-Mobile has a plan with its 5G hotspot that comes with 100GB of data for $60 per month. If you know you're going to be working or staying away from a dedicated connection consistently, it makes sense to add one to your account, but the rest of us don't always know when we'll need the connection.

Carriers will always compete with one another, whether it's in terms of coverage, services, or simply prices. As time goes on, plans will get more data, including mobile hotspots, but it's still likely to lag behind. Limiting mobile hotspot data makes a lot of sense to carriers trying to sell you on a tablet or hotspot plan. Still, with the increase in the popularity and usefulness of wearables, there's a good chance we'll all be using our mobile hotspots a lot more than before.

Samuel Contreras

When Samuel is not writing about networking or 5G at Android Central, he spends most of his time researching computer components and obsessing over what CPU goes into the ultimate Windows 98 computer. It's the Pentium 3.

  • Carriers (especially in the US where they've been allowed to gouge the public) will charge for it just because they can. People are used to paying for it at this point. It'll take some kind of industry disruption to change I think.
  • Carriers always claimed that they needed to throttle heavy data users, so they could guarantee an enjoyable experience for everyone on their network. We know this is not true. Take T-Mobile for example, their current 5G Magenta Max plans is marketed as having unlimited "Premium data". WTF is Premium data? This plan allows you to stream 4k videos without any high speed data cap or throttling. WHAT?!?!?!?!? All of a sudden they are able to accommodate heavy data use? They are even able to offer home internet using the same 5G network. I'm sure they'll claim that they have more spectrum after the purchase of Sprints' mid-band, but that's them being disingenuous. Should carriers continue to limit mobile hotspots now that 5G is here? They shouldn't have in the first place, with 4G or LTE.
  • I use T-Mobile 55+ Magenta Max plan. $65 total per month (auto pay) with the 40GB hot-spot. I have no other internet plan at all any more. Saves me around 50 per month. I keep thinking about the T-Mobile internet access = $50 per month and lowering my cell plan. But at best it will still cost me about $20 more per month going this way...and all my internet data is stuck at home. Not to mention some of the reviews for their internet service are not too favorable. By sticking with the cell plan I currently have I can go anywhere a signal is available and have the same internet service I have as I type this. Using my hotspot all day uses more battery...but that's why we have rapid charging when needed.
  • That's an interesting perspective. The 55+ Magenta Max plan is a really great plan. I'm surprised more people aren't using it. If you can get by with 40GB of hotspot, it sounds like the perfect solution.
  • "should carriers to continue limiting..."
    No. Just, no.
    No limiting, period.
    They shouldn't have been limiting in the first place.
  • I'm glad you're talking about hot spots & tethering, but you missed a big point here. The fact that carriers are charging at ALL for something that they're not even allowed to restrict anymore, per Federal court ruling years ago, is the bigger issue. I don't, atm, recall the name of the case & I don't have the time to look it up right now, but the carriers were definitely forbidden to restrict hotspotting or tethering years ago. How their skirting of the rules has escaped scrutiny and sanction so far is utterly beyond me.
  • Thanks for the tip. I’ll definitely try to track that down.