Google's replacement for third-party cookies on Chrome is being blocked by other platforms
What you need to know
- Third-party web browsers are speaking out against Google's FLoC technology.
- The Chromium-based browsers and search engines dispute Google's claim that FLoC protects user privacy.
- FLoC is currently being tested in the Chromium browser engine.
Google has been touting its new FLoC technology for some time, explaining how it can help preserve user privacy while giving advertisers similar results to third-party cookies. The technology, which is meant to eventually replace third-party cookies, is currently being tested in Google Chrome, but not everyone is happy about it. Advertisers initially pushed back on the technology, but now some of the best Chrome desktop alternatives that are speaking out against it.
In a series of statements, Brave, Vivaldi, and DuckDuckGo are all voicing their concerns over Google's FLoC technology, which groups users into "cohorts" based on similar browsing histories so that third-party advertisers can target groups instead of individuals. The idea is that the approach is less invasive and more anonymous than third-party cookies thanks to local data processing, as explained by our Jerry Hildenbrand. Unfortunately, not everyone agrees that it's the best approach.
The DuckDuckGo search engine was the first to speak out last week, highlighting how Google automatically enabled it for millions of users without first offering a choice:
Brave has called out Google's claims for FLoC as "misleading," since the problem with third-party cookies tracking users on the best Android phones mainly applies to Chrome:
Vivaldi highlights the large-scale problems with FLoC and how it can affect user-privacy in certain societies:
All three platforms have blocked Google's FLoC technology, meaning anyone who uses them does not have to manually opt-out. If you do use Chrome and wish to disable FLoC, you have to go into your Privacy and Security settings and choose "Block third-party cookies." You can also make sure to make your Chrome searches invisible with Incognito mode, and while that alone won't stop ads from targeting you, enabling extensions like DuckDuckGo will.
Nonetheless, this is an unfortunate setback for Google's Privacy Sandbox, which is already getting some heat in an ongoing lawsuit against Google's monopoly over ads on its platforms. Google will have to do more convincing if it hopes to make this new technology a standard or go back to the drawing board and figure out a new way to collect our data.
Get the Android Central Newsletter
Instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
Derrek is a long-time Nokia and LG fanboy who loves astronomy, videography, and sci-fi movies. When he's not working, he's most likely working out or smoldering at the camera.
Why somebody still uses Chrome these days is beyond me anyway. There are faster, better and more private alternatives out there. If people weren't just too lazy to educate themselves! 🙄