Nothing ear (1) vs. Ear (stick): Which should you buy?

Nothing ear (1) vs Ear (stick): What's the same

There are a lot of similarities between the ear (1) and Ear (stick), and inconsistent naming convention aside, Nothing nailed the design brief with both earbuds. They share a similar design for the stalk that sees a clear housing showcasing the insides. It is an interesting design, and while I would have liked to see a clear coat for the shell as well, that isn't the case.

That said, the plastic chassis feels good, and it is durable — I've used both 'buds for several months now, and they're going strong. The case also deserves a mention here as that adds a lot of character to each earbud. The ear (1) has a square case with an indentation on one side, and it does a good job holding the earbuds. I like the design of the case and the fact that it is easily pocketable, but one issue is that it tends to scratch easily.

The Ear (stick) has a cylindrical case that looks more elegant, but it isn't as good for pocketability. While I like the smooth twist action and the attention to detail here, I'm partial to the more muted design of the ear (1) case.

Both earbuds have ingress protection of some kind, with the ear (1) offering an IPX4 rating while the Ear (stick) has IP54. So while both earbuds have the same level of water ingress protection, the Ear (stick) has dust protection as well.

Now, as for the sound quality itself, there is a lot to like with both earbuds. The ear (1) has a dynamic sound that lends itself well to a lot of genres, and it is among the best wireless earbuds at least when it comes to the soundstage. The Ear (stick) builds on that by delivering a rich and full sound with a thoroughly engaging bass, good timbre, and an airiness that's missing on the ear (1).

Both earbuds sound great, but it's clear that Nothing took the time to tune the Ear (stick), and that is noticeable when using both earbuds next to each other. You don't get the AptX codec, but I found both earbuds to be just fine for streaming Spotify or YouTube over SBC.

Nothing ear (1) vs Ear (stick): What's different?

The ear (1) follows a similar design aesthetic to most earbuds in this segment, offering silicone ear tips that nuzzle into your ear cavity. I like this design as I get a tight seal that doesn't budge even during workouts, and they're light enough that I don't feel fatigued even after extended use.

The Ear (stick) come with a bulbous shell that doesn't have an angled sound nozzle, so it doesn't quite nuzzle into your ear. Nothing says that this half in-ear design is aimed at those that don't like the fit of the ear (1), and while I'm not a huge fan of the design, I have to admit that the earbuds don't cause as much fatigue as the ear (1).

As for the shell design, the ear (1) has a glossy coat for the shell while the Ear (stick) is decked out in matte, and the Ear (stick) has a stalk that's slightly elongated, so controlling volume and music playback is a little more easy. That said, one of the downsides of the design is that they don't create a tight seal, and that means you miss out in a few areas.

The key omission is ANC; the Ear (stick) has passive noise isolation, and it works well in most use cases, but the lack of ANC means they are not well-suited if you work in a noisy environment. The ear (1) doesn't have any such drawbacks, and the earbuds do a great job tuning out the noise in your vicinity.

But because of the lack of noise isolation, the Ear (stick) lasts over six hours with a single charge, easily an hour more than the ear (1). The case has enough charge for 22 hours of playback, so you'll only need to charge these earbuds once a week. On that note, there's no wireless charging here — the cylindrical case doesn't allow for it.

Nothing ear (1) vs Ear (stick): Which should you buy?

For my money, I'd get the ear (1). You get more value for your money, and the earbuds do a fabulous job in all areas. The design is intriguing, you get excellent noise isolation and good sound quality, and you don't miss out on any of the extras.

The Ear (stick) is a good alternative if you don't like the way the ear (1) fit, but know that they aren't as good a value. Nothing did a great job with the overall design and tuning of these earbuds, but they miss out in a few areas as well. If you want the best sound quality and don't mind the omissions, the Ear (stick) is what you should get. If you want an all-rounder, get the ear (1).

Only one issue: the ear (1) isn't actually on sale in all markets, with Nothing nudging users to get the Ear (stick) instead. India is a key region for the brand, and the ear (1) has been unavailable after November 2022. It's unlikely that it will be restocked, so if you're looking to buy Nothing's earbuds in India in 2023, you will need to get the Ear (stick).