Netgear and eero each take a rather different approach when it comes to building a mesh Wi-Fi network. Eero makes the most of a few different products — the eero routers work with more eero routers, the eero Beacon, or even the eero Pro. This is simpler than Netgear's buffet of options, which include a cable modem, a speaker, multiple routers, and satellites. The simplicity of the eero makes it a much easier product to understand but with a cost significantly higher than the Orbi, it doesn't seem worth it.
Coverage and quality
Either of these products can create a strong and reliable mesh network that will keep your devices running strong as you move through your home. It's easy to get caught up in the raw speed capabilities of a router but for most people, anything a modern Wi-Fi 5 (802.11AC) router can output will be more than enough. Both of these routers also bring along multi-user, multiple-input, multiple-output (MU-MIMO) technology that keeps the network performing consistently even with a lot of connections.
|NETGEAR Orbi RBK22||eero 3-pack|
|AC Wi-Fi speed||AC2200||N/A|
|CPU||710 Mhz quad-core||700 Mhz quad-core|
|Coverage||2,000 sq ft per unit
4,000 sq ft total
|1,500 sq ft per unit
5,000 sq ft total
With its speed being more than enough for most usage, Eero sets its sights on simplicity and subtlety. The eeros do blend in well with any room's decor so they can be placed in an area with the best signal to the main router. This will keep speeds consistent and useful.
The Orbi system can deliver faster speeds but its bigger package and variety make it slightly more cumbersome to set up efficiently. However, if you are willing to put in the extra time needed in setup, you can build a faster mesh Wi-Fi system and still save money over eero.
What's up with Eero's speed?
Eero doesn't disclose the exact wireless speeds that any of its routers are capable of but in our testing we have found them to be capable of speeds over 400Mbps which should be more than enough for standard usage including 4K streaming.
Eero recommends the base eero product for connections up to 350Mbps and will be capable of delivering this speed with a good mesh connection. The eero Pro can take that up to 550Mbps thanks to tri-band Wi-Fi but you'll be paying significantly more for it. While speeds over 100Mbps will be enough for pretty much anything you do on your PC or tablet, if you download a lot and want a higher maximum throughput, a wired connection will be your best approach with eero.
Coverage, and simplicity
It can be hard to tell how well Wi-Fi signals will travel through your home but Netgear has put together some recommendations on its website to help you pick a package that makes sense for you.
Knowing exactly which product you should use with Orbi can be a little daunting at first with Netgear offering two satellite mesh points, a wall-plug satellite, an outdoor satellite, and a smart speaker. The more powerful units are larger and carry a higher price. The router in this Orbi package is the RBR20 can cover 2,000 square feet with the same coverage on the RBS20 satellite bringing the total to 4,000 square feet.
Eero makes the choice a little easier, though a bit less flexible. It offers its dual-band eeros and eero Beacons covering 1,500 and 1,000 square feet respectively, and the tri-band eero Pro, which covers 1,750 square feet as expansion options. All of these Eero devices will work together but you'll want to keep the fastest router connected to your modem. So if you have an eero Pro, it should be connected to your modem with the other eero routers making up the rest of the mesh.
This three-pack of standard eeros covers 5,000 square feet, but you should keep in mind that this measurement isn't perfect. There will be some overlap and other elements like concrete walls and HVAC systems will reduce the total coverage. Both devices do have an available gigabit Ethernet port so a wired device can be connected with little to no speed sacrifice.
Size and aesthetics
The main router for the Orbi is larger than the eero, but it's far from ugly. In a rounded white housing, it almost looks like modern art when placed next to a conventional router. It does not hide as well as the eero router, so if you want your Wi-Fi setup to be completely hidden, it will be more of a challenge.
When it comes to setting up a good mesh network, the most important thing is your needs. If the eero's more limited coverage per unit and lower potential speed is too much of a sacrifice for you, something effective could be created from the wider Orbi ecosystem. With higher Wi-Fi speeds, greater coverage, and a much lower price tag, the Orbi series is a better candidate for your new home Wi-Fi network.
Big but capable
A bunch of options
Fast speeds and a ton of compatible accessories make the Netgear Orbi one of the most versatile mesh options available. This router delivers high Wi-Fi speeds and modern technology to keep your connection fast and efficient.
Easy on the eyes
As simple as possible
The impressively small size of eero combined with its high-end technology makes this one of the easiest and most powerful mesh networks you can get. The fact that it can be easily tucked away makes it a product that can go in any room of the house.
We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.
Future-proof your home with these Wi-Fi 6 routers
Wi-Fi 6 has arrived and promises speeds of up to 10Gbps by combining both the 2.4GHz and two 5GHz networks in your home. Here are the best compatible routers to take advantage of the faster speeds and greater capacity of Wi-Fi 6.
Get most of Plume's benefits without the required subscription
If you want a Wi-Fi system with plenty of extra security features and great support there are more options than ever. eero Pro offers fast 802.11ac performance with the option of eero Secure and eero Secure+ for those that want to take the guesswork out of internet security.
Switch to a faster router using Best Buy's curbside pickup service
Now is the best time to pick up a new router for your home. With everyone working from home for the foreseeable future, it makes sense to get a router that delivers reliable Wi-Fi connectivity to all corners of your house. These are the best options available right now, and you can pick them up without leaving your car thanks to Best Buy's curbside pickup service.