CIQ

Say hello to my little friend

Yep. That's exactly what it looks like — Carrier IQ running on AT&T's new LG G2. Robstunner in our forums was poking around on his new G2, as Android users are prone to do, and found this lurking there, like the monster under the bed. Unless you're rooted, you're not going to be able to get it off or stop it from doing its business, either.

I'm not going to tell you how to feel about this one. Carrier IQ — when correctly implemented — is no more invasive than all the other loggers and system trackers manufacturers and carriers install on every phone. But I'm not about to suggest that this makes it OK. That's for you to decide. 

My only suggestion if you want to be free of all this sort of hidden software is to use a burner Tracfone. Comments are open, have at it.

Source: G2 Forums

 

Reader comments

The AT&T LG G2 has a familiar face on board - Carrier IQ

58 Comments

Why should the carriers now anything about me? I mean they already know plenty, and I give them money so why?

Posted via The Android Central App

Because they can, and somewhere nestled in all of the papers you sign/click during your account creation you agree to it. It helps them get statistics about how their phones and networks are being used, and apparently not enough people care that much about it and keep using the carriers. Nobody has given them any reason NOT to do it.

Posting from my Verizon LG G2, I can confirm the Verizon G2 does not have it at least according to this app. Shocking, something bad Verizon actually didn't do?!

There's a thread on XDA about it too. (I believe it's been around longer than what was brought up here.) Both the AT&T and T-Mobile have it although Verizon's variant has no signs of it.

Hell yes they do! On the other hand, you have the option to opt-out if you choose. (I still question whether that does anything or not.)

It disables it. I did that with my G2, and it reads as it being present but inactive. T-mobile also makes it clear that you can opt out, so if you do they wouldn't violate that choice. (T-mobile seems to be generally more responsive in this area than Verizon or AT&T)

Key words "when correctly implemented" if it then there's nothing to worry about. If not, well that's a horse of a different color

That's the point though, all carriers and manufacturers have some form of this on their phones. Some will be more invasive some will be less but you're foolish if you think your phone is completely free of this stuff (hence the burner phone suggestion).

And another reason to root and ROM. I generally will trust a dev more than a carrier. Especially if I want a 'stock, skinned' ROM with all the bloat stripped out. Scotts roms are where I usually start with a new device

Posted via your wifes, girlfriends phone

Hey im famous! Yea, I don't appreciate the spying type (even if its "innocent"), which is why im on a CIQ-free Moto X :) There is no reason I shouldn't have ANY wakelock because AT&T is doing R&D with what im doing on my phone.

The CIQ decection apps all catch it, XDA has a how to on how to block the CIQ agents but you need to be rooted. Moto X does not have CIQ.

You do know that Google knows everything about you. And the moto x is always listening to you.

Posted via Android Central App

there is a difference between always listening for a specific word... and always listening and recording whats going on and transmitting to servers somewhere.

Ehhh, I think AT&T.I have nationwide 4GLTE, no dropped calls and its unlimited data. So I'm good.

Posted via Android Central App

I often wonder, do the people who make the decisions realize that if something is nefarious or quasi nefarious techies will find it and expose it.

I realize that CIQ is potentially not a problem, but seriously what were the people thinking who Green Lighted the inclusion of CIQ?

Dan

They were thinking they'd get tons of usable data, and they probably did... CIQ may have been a high profile amongst enthusiasts but the average Joe probably never heard of CIQ or forgot about it already, and it's not like enthusiast's opinion were gonna sway the average Joe one way or the other since most carriers and several OEM were using it.

Posting from my Verizon LG G2, I can confirm the Verizon G2 does not have it at least according to this app. Shocking, something bad Verizon actually didn't do?

No CarrierIQ on AT&T HTC ONE ... yet. 4.3 rollout is coming soon. I'll be checking it again after that.

Odd they would single out the G2 for it.

They just changed the name. Look in Settings > About > Tell HTC and error reporting.

Every phone from every carrier has something like this. Smart OEM's let you turn it off (or say you're turning it off). Keeping the name Carrier IQ was a pretty stupid move on this one. That name is ruined.

Doesn't HTC's error reporting tool actually ask you for permission each and every time an error occurs and it wants to phone home tho? Or does it invariably phone home at other times regardless of crashes etc?

Agreed, CIQ is a tarnished brand and I am scratching my head wondering why at&t would allow it's inclusion, just call it something else.

Granted I do not work in the consumer space, but after having an issue with a sub vendor doing some naughty things my employer was quick to respond and from now on QC ensures that their name and more importantly their products no longer appears in our products.

Dan

Posted via Android Central App

Makes sense they'd rename it. Is that path correct? I looked all over my ONE's settings including Help>About and see no reference to "Tell HTC" or error reporting. Or do you have to be root to see it?

Why buy a phone, from a company that does not know how to execute? I'd sooner buy a Windows Phone or an iPhone. At least, those platforms have a future in the consumer market. No thanks, but nice try anyway, lol.

Isn't it past your bedtime?

I have an AT&T Optimus G, the predecessor to this phone, and it doesn't have it. Odd they would start with the 2nd gen

Posted via Android Central App

The T-mobile version does have it, but you can turn it off. The Supercurio authored IQ detector app verifies that its inactive when you turn it off.

Also, the mere presence of it is not cause for alarm...yet. After the original episode, and the blowback, there were likely significant changes to how the software works and how the data is handled. It is simply too early to be reacting with 'ZOMG CARRIER IQ!!!!!!111111' when we have no idea what the current software implementation entails.

I had already given up the idea of this phone as the screen has gorilla glass 2 and I'm sure I'll crack the screen in about four months. The size makes it too big to add a case to it. I know I would be too uncomfortable with it.

That's your only suggestion?

Here's a better suggestion: Rom the damn thing and get rid of all carrier crapola, because I'm pretty sure they dev community will have a ROM with that POS stripped out by the time this article is a day or two old, if they already haven't.