Fortnite for mobile is no stranger to controversy. Starting out as a timed exclusive for Samsung phones through Galaxy Apps, then as an open release through Epic's own site, and finally making its way to the Google Play Store made sure that everyone was talking about Fortnite even if they had no intentions of ever playing it. Even the iOS release was a drawn-out affair with a very limited beta release but plenty of coverage. Epic made sure everyone with a smartphone knew about Fortnite.
All of this pales to the latest Fortnite disaster. Apple and Google have removed the Epic Games app — which is how you install and play the game — from their respective stores after Epic tried to circumnavigate the policies of both. It seems that Epic wanted to redirect users who wanted to purchase in-game currency to its own payment processor and bypass Apple and Google's to get around the 30% cut each takes from purchases. Since that's 100% against the rules of both platforms, Apple and Google removed the Epic Games app and Epic is suing them both because of it.
This sort of thing happens every day, but this time is a bit different because of the scale. Fortnite is by any measure a wild success with millions and millions of mobile users who are willing to spend millions and millions of dollars. All those users are now pawns in what should be a business dispute.
But didn't you read what they said? Multi-billion dollar Epic and billionaire Tim Sweeney are here to fight for openness and fairness on behalf of little developers everywhere! 😂😂😂But didn't you read what they said? Multi-billion dollar Epic and billionaire Tim Sweeney are here to fight for openness and fairness on behalf of little developers everywhere! 😂😂😂— iPad Insight (@iPadInsightBlog) August 14, 2020August 14, 2020
Android users have it a little easier. We can sideload the Epic Games app directly from Epic or through another third-party store and I'm sure plenty who want to install Fortnite on a new phone will do just that. Epic doesn't like this solution and claims that Android forces users to click dozens of times to install an app from outside of Google Play and that their phones tell them that the game client is malware.
That's a broad mischaracterization of the actual process, but many of Epic's claims in its legal filings are. Lawyers are the masters of interpreting things differently to suit their needs so we shouldn't be surprised when we read claims that aren't 100% genuine, like Google doesn't allow third-party app stores to be used as a primary source (see Samsung or LG) or that no app is allowed to download newer versions or update itself outside of the Play Store (see Facebook). The truth is close to that, though, and Epic is trying to get its point across with damning accusations.
On the other end of the spectrum, we have Apple. Apple is the very definition of a closed system and the only way for most users to install Fortnite is through the App Store. If you Jailbreak your iPhone, you have other means, but few people are willing to take that risk or work that hard. Even for Fortnite.
This isn't anything new. The most recent example would be Microsoft's xCloud game streaming app, which Apple has blocked until Microsoft is willing to submit every game that a user can stream for individual approval. Apple has quoted rules as to why this is a requirement, but it seems a strange hill to die on — especially when Apple has shown it is willing to bend those rules for other companies like Amazon.
Epic's claims against Apple hold a little more water because of all this. Apple has complete control and many would say draconian rules over the entire platform and when Epic says this is anti-competitive, it is hard to argue. But Epic may be the worst company of the three.
Epic's claims all fall apart when you consider that the company (presumably) read and understood the rules when it decided to place the Epic Games store on each platform or when it decided that it wanted to bypass the 30% transaction fees that both Apple and Google charge. Full stop — Epic decided those rules were fair enough and now it says they are not.
It is Epic that has decided you can't install Fortnite through your phone's app store. The company willingly broke the terms it agreed to after it gained millions and millions of new users and thought that this would give them a little bit of leverage. Apple and Google may have pulled the switch, but Epic put the noose around its own neck.
But really, all three companies are wrong in one regard: they are willing to place users in the middle of what should be a business dispute. If you play Fortnite, you are not doing anything wrong; you're simply enjoying the phone you spent a lot of money to buy. If any of the three cared about you, they would have done whatever it takes to keep the Epic Games app in the store.
Apple and Google spend a lot of money to maintain their application markets. They also share a few responsibilities when it comes to security and content. Is a 30% fee too much to ask of a developer? Maybe. I think it is, but I'm not building and running my own app store for billions of users. While each company has to do a few things with our bests interests in mind, the real purpose of having an app store is to make money. A 30% transaction fee is a good way to do it.
Epic Games' reason to exist is the same: money. Epic isn't your friend nor your enemy and to it, you only exist as a number attached to a dollar sign. This is still a good reason why Epic should want you to be a satisfied customer, though — a happy customer is willing to spend more money, especially on a freemium game like Fortnite.
Epic's willingness to break the terms of its contract tells us that it wants to cause enough uproar that Apple and Google will relent and give it a special deal or apply special rules. And that might happen; Fortnite is a pretty big deal and there are plenty of people who like the game enough to stand with Epic on the whole mess.
In the end, though, everyone involved is wrong. Epic should follow the rules so its app stays in Google Play and the App Store while all three companies try to resolve the issue. Even if that means going to court. None of this is our fault but we are also being punished.
I disagree. When Apple pulls a Dark Sky they are showing they don't give a crap about their customers. Good on Epic here. Just wait a couple days while the iPhone crybabies can't play their fortnight. It will be hilarious and Apple is going to suffer for it. Some of these kids will absolutely jump ship when they see their Android friends playing along uninterrupted. That said, this is really all about greed and there are no good guys. But its yet another example where Apple's stupid "garden walls" are just covering a porta potty.
What does Apple buying an app have anything to do with this? For the record, the Fortnite app on both platforms will continue to work. It just won't be updated for either of them.
i sideload plenty of apps. i just downloaded/ sideloaded Fortnite on my Android Samsung Galaxy S9+, no Google Store required, not even on wifi- sweet VZW real Unltd, grandfathered data. working great. It sure will be updated no problem.
Epic is doing a great thing to educate millions and millions of mobile users that users have a choice- chose Android, and users can sideload programs and stores, to their heart’s delight. Apple’s closed system is one reason why I’ve never owned anything Apple.
But they're not. Their lawsuit specifically says that isn't a solution.
they're not what? maybe their lawsuit specifically says that isn't a solution, but I just beautifully sideloaded Fortnite on my Galaxy, working beautifully
As explained in this very article, their lawsuit is also full of half-truth and misinformation.
The conclusion of this blog post is wrong. If the two stores are engaging in anti-competitive behavior, the fact that Epic accepted it in the past is not a reason for them to continue to accept it. Just because you have accepted abuse for years is no excuse to continue taking it. Not having access to a mobile game for a while is a first-world problem. Let this play out in court and maybe we will have even more options in the future.
The court is going to ask why they accepted it the first time though, and epic won't have a good answer.
Epic accepted it first time because it needed the stores to build an audience. Now that it does, including me- I just now downloaded Fortnite for the first time, Epic now has the clout to call out the Stores' BS
I have issues with the Stores charging 30%. Why can they support free apps but take a CHUNK from the ones that charge? Do free apps have to pay Google/Apple a "hosting" fee? Which honestly I could understand since hosting costs money. But the fee should be the same in either case. One option is the Stores could make their money on ads for the apps. So Epic buys a Store ad to promote Fortnight, then the Stores makes money. As far as MS xCloud, Apple is wrong, as this should be no different than Amazon's or Netflix's movie or Spotify's songs catalogs.
I find it weird how Epic complains about the 30% cut from Google/Apple and yet only discounted the purchase prices through their own payment process by 20%. That's 10% unaccounted for.
Goes to cover increased expenses...?
How is it ok for big box stores or Amazon to have an app on ios or Android and a customer able to buy items from them without google and Apple taking a cut? There are plenty of other examples, just a few here. Are they not making in app purchases? How is it different? Please explain...
Without taking "a cut"... 30 %!
Of every transaction!
For doing practically nothing! PWA's can't come quickly enough!!!
Should Mercedes of Toyota also get 30 % of all gasoline sales?!?
'Epic decided those rules were fair enough' They have continuously and openly described the terms as unfair. The fact that they HAD to abide by them to stay in business can't be on their shoulders. I'm all with Epic on this one; with a little luck this will be the first nail in the coffin for the duopoly...!
This is what happens when you only have two major no phone OS says every former BlackBerry and Windows Mobile user. App developers only wanted to make apps for iOS and Android? There you go. Eat what you made.
Get the best of Android Central in in your inbox, every day!
Thank you for signing up to Android Central. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.