The U.S., Canada, and the U.K. have all advised participants in the Winter Olympics 2022, held in Beijing, to leave their phones, tablets, and laptops at home. Instead, asking athletes to rely on burner phones for communication while abroad. The Netherlands, Sweden, and Switzerland went a step further and will provide "disposable" devices to their Olympic teams, which will be destroyed once they return home. Expect more of this sort of thing as we approach the Feb. 4 opening for the Winter Olympic Games.
It's easy to reduce this reaction as some sort of xenophobic or racially charged screed, but if that's what you're here for I will gleefully disappoint you. Having said that, I do think this is the right reaction from the governments involved.
Let me stop you right there. Wonderful people live in and were born in China. I've never been, but I'm told it's also a beautiful country steeped in rich history and culture. The problem is the government. Specifically, its laws surrounding the use of electronic devices. To be blunt: In China, the laws say that the government can surveil all people within the borders of China and censor the things they "say" on the internet or over any electronic medium. And in this case, "can" means totally does.
In the U.S. (and Canada, the U.K., and plenty of other countries) the government can also track movements and spy on online communications. All that's needed is a slip of paper signed by a judge. That small piece of paper is there to protect the rights of citizens, and while it's not always effective, it is a safeguard. The bigger difference is that most countries aren't too concerned about what the average person does online or where they travel. China may not be very concerned either, but it tracks people anyway — no slip of paper and no judge is necessary.
Collecting today for access later
I'm not privy to what goes on in government sessions in China, but I do know enough about paperwork that I'm positive there isn't a giant windowless building filled with workers that actively track every single person living in or visiting China. There doesn't need to exist because a computer is fully capable of tracking everything about you and storing the data for handy retrieval at a later date. China collects today so it has access later, while the U.S. waits for a need then collects the data it needs to access today.
I'm not here to say which is the better way because I think there should be an even bigger right to privacy than anything we have now. I'm just explaining that China collecting data on "everyone" is a real thing that's mostly tolerated by the people of China. It's certainly expected and the government isn't trying to keep all this a secret. That's how it's done, and those are the rules.
Smoke and mirrors
Information is successfully tracked using the simple things we all have on our phones: apps. Yes, the carrier and the company writing the operating system also make it easier for government surveillance, but that pales in comparison when you think about how easily an app can do it. Apps routinely request your location, and accept input on the things you type or even say out loud. Apps even track how you use other apps and if they can get away with doing so. Think about it. When we buy the best Android phone, one of the first things we do is install all of our favorite apps.
Some apps and services like Facebook and Twitter are officially blocked in China. Needless to say, athletes from visiting countries will certainly want to use them anyway, and there is a greater than normal risk for state-sponsored "spy" software or even real malware once users start to try dodgy things they've read about on the internet.
I assume (yes, I know one should never do it) that most reading this are aware on some level that China tracks the people in its borders using their smartphones. I will also assume that most everyone reading this is not an Olympic athlete with rigorous training schedules who lives a life very focused on a thing that isn't related to technology, like downhill skiing, for example.
This is why the governments of countries that offer a bit more online privacy (or at least the appearance of it) have a responsibility to tell their Olymipains they shouldn't be lugging their expensive new phone to China. The actual risk of exposing digital data is just too high to not suggest it.
Makes sense. I doubt every Olympian would just use a VPN. They probably don't have the knowledge to do so. Burner phone it is when in China.
I'd strongly recommend against using a VPN in China.
I’ve visited China several times. You must login using your passport # anytime you access the internet there. I always use a VPN. One time I posted a picture and comment on my Facebook page that had something to do with China. Within 15 minutes the post was gone and I could not connect to my VPN the remainder of my visit. It’s no joke.
No accusations of xenophobia here. I'm just wondering why the USA and other countries have not backed out of the Olympics, if for any reason other than the one million Uyghurs living in slave camps. But throw in Hong Kong, and how their people are treated.
If I was xenophobic my sister-in-law (born in the ROC) would kick me where it hurts the most the next time I saw here, and how would I look at my two nephews and niece? And she is also wondering why anyone would allow the Olympics to be presented in the PRC.
It's all about the money...business, advertising fees, TV ratings + hits and clicks.
And the athletes. Don't forget about them. These folks train their whole lives, in fact training is their whole life. Denying them the opportunity to compete on a world stage would be hard to justify. It's not like China has changed since the Olympic Committee selected them to host. Maybe a bad choice, considering, but hosting the Olympics is not something that every country is capable of. Those that are are all likely objectionable to someone.
This. This is my question. The Uyghurs, the various other human rights violations. The attempts to claim Taiwan - my step-mom is Taiwanese. She, my dad, and my sisters live there and I worry about them if China ever decides to act on their threats.
Small sacrifice for keeping at least some of your personal info somewhat safe...maybe. Taking a couple of cameras and/or video cams still captures all those moments that are once-in-a-lifetime.
I thought "three subjects + oh my!" titles ended in 2018...
Get the best of Android Central in in your inbox, every day!
Thank you for signing up to Android Central. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.