Do you prefer in-screen or traditional fingerprint sensors?

We've seen a lot of smartphone trends so far in 2019, one of which being in-screen fingerprint sensors. The idea of having a fingerprint sensor hidden underneath a phone's display is incredibly cool, and on devices like the OnePlus 7 Pro, the end result is surprisingly great.

However, as futuristic and flashy as the feature may be, are in-screen sensors really any better than traditional ones?

Here's what some of our AC forum members have to say.

I've only had one of each and honestly I think the back was better because if you've been keeping up with the S10 at all there are dozens of mentions of screen protectors and the FPS. By far my strongest feeling that the rear FPS is better is based on screen protection. I'm not a huge screen protector advocate but if the FPS wasn't in the screen picking a protector would be a breeze and not...

VidJunky

rear dedicated FP sensor, without question. I had S9+, moved to S10+. Overall I thought I liked the S9+ better--and the rear FPS was a big part of it. I recently bought another S9+ for testing with another carrier, and I've fallen in love with it all over again. Superb phone, AND the rear FPS rocks. I rarely use the front sensor on the S10, but when I do, it's problematic no matter what....

Adam Frix

Rear, but I think once the front FPS is improved I will change my mind. They need to make the FPS area bigger and more reliable in the screen.

strikeIII

I like the in glass FPS. It's early and it's the way of the future. It will only get better. The RPS has been around a lot longer and it took some time to perfect. I'm more than willing to give it a chance as the technology improves.

jbjtkbw007

Now, we want to hear from you. Do you prefer in-screen or traditional fingerprint sensors?

Join the conversation in the forums!

Joe Maring

Joe Maring was a Senior Editor for Android Central between 2017 and 2021. You can reach him on Twitter at @JoeMaring1.

Read more
Applying a tempered glass screen protector to a OnePlus 13
I want to like ultrasonic fingerprint sensors, but they just don't work for me
Huawei Watch Ultimate
Huawei follows Apple, Samsung with intriguing fingerprint smartwatch idea
Comparing the display sizes of the Google Pixel 9 Pro to the Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
These Google-certified Pixel 9 screen protectors shouldn't mess with your fingerprint
Hands-on with the smaller Samsung Galaxy S24
The Galaxy S24 might have faster fingerprint unlocks with One UI 7 beta
Sundar Pichai at Google I/O 2024 describing Google Gemini AI
Smartphones have reached their peak, so what could possibly be next?
Vivo X200 Pro next to X200, Find X8, Find X8 Pro, and Pixel 9 Pro
Smartphones in 2025 are fun again — if you look beyond the carriers
Latest in Phones
The back of the Obsidian Google Pixel 9 Pro
Some Pixel owners had a delayed start, thanks to alarm clock failures
Holding an Obsidian Google Pixel 9 Pro
That's not a typo — this Google Pixel 9 Pro deal from Amazon makes Black Friday look like a joke
Leaked image of a blue Galaxy Z Flip 7
New Galaxy Z Flip 7 case leak backs rumors of a larger cover display
Android Central's Lloyd sitting at a computer desk
Editor's Desk
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 on cobblestone road
One UI 7 Beta 3 for the Galaxy Z Flip 6, Fold 6 brings two notable AI additions
Nothing Phone 3a Pro
Nothing OS 3.1 update lets Phone 3a, 3a Pro users snap and save to Essential Spaces
Latest in News
YouTube Music home screen
YouTube Music's personalized radio stations are getting even smarter
The back of the Obsidian Google Pixel 9 Pro
Some Pixel owners had a delayed start, thanks to alarm clock failures
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra Home Screen - 16x9
Heads up — Samsung's detailed One UI 7 rollout schedule for Galaxy appears
The old Android logo at Google's Pier 57 building in New York City
Report claims Google may move to 'privately' develop Android's future
Leaked image of a blue Galaxy Z Flip 7
New Galaxy Z Flip 7 case leak backs rumors of a larger cover display
The Google Maps logo at the Google Maps Street View Garage
Google Maps might predict more than just the traffic for you soon