Skip to main content

YouTube is testing a floating comment bar on landscape videos and we're here for it

YouTube Axon 10 Pro
YouTube Axon 10 Pro (Image credit: Jason England / Android Central)

What you need to know

  • Users have reported seeing a new layout for YouTube comments.
  • The layout appears when users switch to a fullscreen view of a video, with comments appearing in a scrollable side panel.
  • The layout appears to be available for only a limited number of users, suggesting it could be part of an A/B test.

YouTube has been working on improving its comment section on the best Android phones, and the latest look shows how the app might plan to incorporate comments while viewing a full-screen video.

Multiple users have reported a "bug" (via Android Police) in the YouTube app that shows the comment section in a scrollable side panel while in landscape mode. The panel appears to allow users to hide or bring up the comment section at will, with the video adjusting in size to accommodate.

YouTube Fullscreen Comments Test

Source: Android Police (Image credit: Source: Android Police)

The transition looks fairly smooth and provides an uninterrupted viewing experience for anyone brave enough to scroll through the comment section. It would save users having to exit out of fullscreen mode in order to leave a comment on a video. It appears that users can also get rid of the side panel by hitting the "X" on the top right corner of the panel.

The new view also appears different from the live chat feed that appears when watching a live video feed.

If this is a test, it wouldn't be the first time we've seen YouTube messing around with the comments section. In March, the app was spotted testing out a few different layouts for how comments appeared underneath the video. However, it's unclear if any of them have stuck.

Until now, the comment section on YouTube has only been viewable when in portrait mode, but many users may prefer landscape mode for a more immersive viewing experience. This would give users a way to engage with videos no matter how they choose to watch them.

The feature doesn't appear to widely available, meaning it is likely a server-side A/B test. That said, YouTube may choose not to expand the rollout of this handy feature, but we'll have to wait and see. Of course, if you're a parent, you can always set up a supervised account for your kids on YouTube to help shield them from the horrors of comments.

Derrek is a long-time Nokia and LG fanboy who loves astronomy, videography, and sci-fi movies. When he's not working, he's most likely working out or smoldering at the camera.

4 Comments
  • I would like to see them test less intrusive ads. I swear they are placed exactly at the spots in a video that you're most interested in seeing. They really know how to irritate the heck out of people. YouTube premium can eat it.
  • YouTube premium is extortion, but totally worth it due to the severe penalty of intrusive ads. Are they going to allow reading notes and comments for videos on Android TV? I doubt it.
  • I've always hated how on desktop you can't read comments and type a comment while also watching the video like you can on mobile. There's gotta be a way they can make this happen
  • How about less censorship, less obnoxious adds and picking on smaller channels and content creators who have "fallen out of favour" with the powers that be...deplatforming and demonetizing all those they deem problematic persona non-grata... That'd be a start. Then again these are the same people who award themselves freedom of speech awards and tout their own supposed stance on censorship and freedom of expression...while at the same time being guilty of the very same things they are supportedly fighting against.